Saturday, April 26, 2014

First Anniversary of Syrian Bishop's Kidnapping

April 22 marked the anniversary of the kidnapping of the two bishops from Aleppo: Syriac Orthodox  Yohanna Ibrahim and Greek Orthodox Boulos Yazigi, who is also a brother of John X, the Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Antioch. Jean Aziz Aziz sums up the status quo for Al Monitor and asks some valid questions on this occasion:

Fate of kidnapped Syrian bishops still unknown, by Jean Aziz, Al Monitor

Friday, April 18, 2014

With the advancement of the of the regime's campaign in the Qalamoun area, the Christian town of Ma‘lula has been retaken. The town is famous for it's monasteries and had been taken by rebel forces in September last year, when some nuns were also kidnapped. During the recent fighting four reporters of Hizballah's al-Manar TV were killed by rebels.

Syrian Christians long to return to Maloula, by Roueida Mabardi, The Daily Star
After Maaloula, Syrian army heads to Zabadani, by Jean Aziz, Al-Monitor

Syria fighting leaves Maaloula, a historic Christian town, in ruins, by Patrick J. McDonnell and Nabih Bulos, Los Angeles Times

Druze Sheikhs Protest in Sweida

A version of this article first appeared on the Carnegie Endowment's blog Syria in Crisis edited by Aron Lund

by Tobias Lang 


Protests led by Druze religious sheikhs erupted in the city of Sweida in southern Syria around April 9. The province of Sweida has an overwhelming majority of Druze, a small religious minority that makes up around 3 percent of Syria’s population.

Few Druze have so far participated in the protests against Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, and the Sweida region has accordingly been spared the worst of the civil war, even though fighting seems to have increased recently. At the beginning of the uprising, the Druze of Sweida generally adopted a more neutral stance. But with the growing prominence of Islamist forces within the opposition, attacks on Druze civilians by rebels, and sectarian manipulation by the regime, the Druze community has been increasingly pushed over to the regime’s side.

The Druze Leadership

There has not been a worldly leader of the Druze in Syria since of the death of Sultan al-Atrash, the hero of the uprising against the French colonial occupation in 1925–1927. This vacuum has led to the relative prominence of the three so-called sheikhs al-aql, who represent the sect vis-à-vis the state authorities, although, contrary to widespread belief, the sheikhs al-aql are not the highest spiritual authority per se.

Two of the sheikhs al-aql have died since the start of the uprising against Assad in March 2011 and been replaced by younger relatives. The remaining sheikh al-aql from the older generation is Hammud al-Hinnawi, who “is today the most influential Syrian Druze public figure,” according to Gary Gambill of the Foreign Policy Research Institute. Overall, Hinnawi has so far presented himself as a rather moderate figure in political terms, without taking a stance against the regime.

Sheikhs Protesting the Government

Sweida has witnessed antigovernment protests before, but they were not as large as in other parts of Syria, nor were they as brutally repressed. This does not mean that a Druze opposition does not exist—it does, and online activists have published a whole list of Druze Syrians killed in prison.

Yet, the current protests are different because they are not led by political activists but by parts of the clergy. According to the Lebanese newspaper Daily Star and the pro-opposition news site Zaman al-Wasl, the initial reason for the protests was that a rally for the upcoming presidential election had featured a dancing woman in a traditional Druze dress holding a picture of Assad. The Daily Star cites an activist according to whom “the [sheikhs], some of whom were armed, assaulted the gathering, wrecked the tent and audio equipment and escorted the woman away.”

According to Zaman al-Wasl, the protests intensified and demanded the ouster of Wafiq Nasser, head of the Military Intelligence Directorate’s local branch in Sweida, after one of the sheikhs leading the protests had been arrested. The reports of armed sheikhs protesting are confirmed by footage circulating on social media and opposition websites.

Traditions and Politics

Druze society is conservative, and many traditional members of the community would see the use of their cultural or religious symbols in an election campaign as a major sign of disrespect, especially if a female is involved. That this would lead to a popular backlash is only normal by Druze standards——even more so because one of the protesting sheikhs was briefly arrested. Neither should the brandishing of guns be overstated in this context. Purely ceremonial shooting in the air is not uncommon and, according to the available reports, no one was seriously wounded.

It is important to realize that while there is a tradition of rebellion in Druze history, it does not necessarily signify complete confrontation with the regime. Sultan al-Atrash’s leadership of the anti-French revolution in the 1920s is a well-known event in Syrian history, and it invariably colors contemporary debate, with any type of Druze protest often labeled a “Druze revolt.” But even if demonstrations turn violent, it would not mean that the Druze would automatically seek to overthrow the regime. Recent examples of local “Druze revolts” in Syria include the protests in Jaramana in 1993 or the sectarian unrest in Sweida in 2000.[i] Neither of these popular mobilizations escalated to a point where they would have seriously challenged the government. Rather, both of these conflicts were defused after mediation by the sheikhs al-aql or government officials.

The current protests were clearly driven by the violation of Druze traditions, not by an agenda to topple the regime. However, my colleague Rami Abou Diab rightfully points out that there is rarely a clear-cut border between defending traditional values and political protest—especially among the Druze. Syrian history provides ample evidence of how parochial concerns can transform into political movements. For example, in a 1922 incident, the French authorities arrested a guest at Sultan al-Atrash’s house, an act perceived as a grave violation of Druze hospitality customs. The month-long clashes that followed could be interpreted as the attempt of a tribal leader to restore his honor but also as an early attempt to start an uprising against the French—which Atrash would in fact do three years later. [ii] 

Protests Defused, for Now

According to credible reports from Sweida, the protests are already over and the controversial military intelligence chief, Wafiq Nasser, has been removed from his position. The sheikhs al-aql did not support the protesters but rather tried to appease them. The mechanisms of mediation between the regime and the sheikhs al-aql seem to be working, just as they did during the unrest in 2000.[iii]

In turn, Assad and his associates seem to have compromised early on by removing Nasser. The regime could ill-afford a weakening of Druze support: Sweida is an essential area for Assad’s government, protecting its southern flank.

In sum, there is no strong evidence supporting the hypothesis of a major Druze uprising
at this stage, but that does not mean the protests lack significance. Even though only a change in the stance of the sheikhs al-aql or the emergence of new independent leaders could potentially alter the relationship of the wider Druze community to the regime, there are in fact some unconfirmed reports of such new leaders emerging—and the quick decision to sacrifice Nasser indicates that the position of the regime in Sweida is not as strong as it once was.

It seems clear that under these circumstances, Druze self-confidence and a sense of political particularism will grow, including toward the regime. The question is to what extent Assad will be able to control this trend.

[i] Schäbler, Birgit (2013): Constructing an Identity between Arabism and Islam: The Druzes of Syria, pp. 75-77, in: The Muslim World, Volume 103, Spring 2013, pp. 62-79.
[ii] See e.g. Provence, Michael (2005): The Great Syrian Revolt and the Rise of Nationalism, pp. 3-5, Austin: University of Texas Press.
[iii]  Schäbler: “Constructing an identity”, pp. 75-77.

Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Why Assad’s Foothold in the Golan Will Endure, by Daniel Stoker, Atlantic Council

A cross-sectarian Assadist iconography

I found this picture a while ago on a pro-Assad Druze Facebook site. I perfectly illustrates the cross-secterian narrative of the Assad-regime and carries some subtle and not so subtle messages, like a Christian iconography.  Beside of Bashar al-Assad we see here Sunni Grand Mufti of Syria Badr ad-Din Hasun (down right), Greek-Catholic (Melikite) Patriach Gregory Lahham (top right), an unidentified Shiite cleric who has similarities with Iraqi sayid Ammar al-Hakim (top center) and a Druze shaikh, maybe shaikh al-‘aql Hammud al-Hinnawi (top left). Credit for identiying goes to Aron Lund.

Saturday, April 12, 2014

The Institute for Stydy of War has published an extremely detailed and well researchrd report on the engagement of Hizballah in Syria:

Hezballah in Syria by Marisa Sullivan, Institute for Stydy of War

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Fascinating report by Anne Bernard, the Beirut bureau chief of the New York Times, from Saiyida Zainab near Damascus, which houses the Shia shrine of the prophet Muhammad's granddaughter (or one of them to be exact). Protecting the shrine serves as a pretense for the involvement of Hizballah and Shia fighters from Iraq in Syria.

Muslim Shrine Stands as a Crossroads in Syria’s Unrest by Anne Bernard, The New York Times

Assad meets newly elected Syriac Orthodox patriach

Ignatius Aphrem II Karim, the newly elected patriarch of the Syriac Orthodox church, leaves little doubt which side he supports in the ongoing civil war in Syria:

Syria's Al-Assad receives Syriac Orthodox Church's new patriarch 
by Sherry El-Gergawi, Al-Ahram
Karim expressed his hope that security and peace would soon prevail in Syria, whose people he said were a shining example of national unity. He further asserted that the Syriac Orthodox Patriarchate supports the Syrian people’s struggle against terrorism and their right to self-determination away from the interference of any foreign side.

Monday, April 7, 2014

There are two more very interesting pieces out on the occasion of Hillal al-Assad's assassination:

Who Was Hilal al-Assad? by Mohammad D., Syria Comment
The Death of an Assad by Aron Lund, Syria in Crisis 

Btw the rumours about the killing of his son Sulayman, which had circulated on Twitter during last week, turned out to be a hoax.

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Map: Funerals of Hezbollah Fighters killed in Syria, as of 29 March 2014 by Hisham Ashkar. He localized no less than 313 funerals and has some other great work on bis Blog mostlyoff as well - strongly recommended.

Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Interview with Armenian MP on Kasab

Interview with Tevan Poghosyan, a member of the Armenian parliament, who has just returned from Latakia (see also here for a next interview). According to him the Armenian side has suffered no casualties and he renews the claims, that the attack on Kasab has been carried out in coordination with Turkey.

Tuesday, April 1, 2014

New Syriac-Orthodox Patriarch elected

Mor Cyril Aphrem Karim, the Archbishop  for the Eastern United States, was elected as 123rd Patriarch of the Syriac Orthodox Church of Antioch. Upon his installation his name will be Ignatius Aphrem II Karim. The new Patriarch is relatively young (just 48) and was born in Qamishli, in Syria's Hasaka province. Judging by his statements in US-media, he is potentially regime leading.